Results 1 to 12 of 12

25.5" vs. 27" Scale?

This is a discussion on 25.5" vs. 27" Scale? within the Music Man Guitars forums, part of the Gear Talk category; Lets assume the guitars are identical. What would be the pros and cons of each scale length....

  1. #1
    Hendog's Avatar
    Hendog is offline Registered User Senior Member
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    giving the Count of Tuscany a Glasgow Kiss
    Posts
    732

    25.5" vs. 27" Scale?

    Lets assume the guitars are identical. What would be the pros and cons of each scale length.
    Last edited by Hendog; 12-20-2009 at 05:31 PM.
    Guitars: EBMM JP 6, EBMM 25th, Ibanez 7 string, Carvin DC127 (on order)
    Amps: Mark V, HT-5, Cube 30, Hot Rod Deluxe, many cabs
    Effects: Carbon Copy, DD-20, Cry Baby Wah, Pitchblack, EVH Phaser


    Great deals with frisco, Astronome, and others

  2. #2
    balance's Avatar
    balance is offline Registered User Senior Member
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    FL and BC
    Posts
    488
    In my experience, on the 27" side tuned to standard E-E tuning, the notes have a fuller sounding timbre to them with a slightly improved intonation; bending the strings was not difficult. I have not tried a JP Baritone tuned standard with its 27.5" scale, though would expect it to be more of the same, if not a slightly harder bending of the notes required.

    A 25.5" or even 24.75" setup properly can have equal intonation though. What are you looking to get out of it?
    1992 EBMM EVH

  3. #3
    walleye is offline Registered User Senior Member
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    Melbourne, Australia
    Posts
    433
    the longer the scale the easier it is to hit harmonics and artificial harmonics.

    in my opinion 27.0" is the smallest scale that can satisfactorily support the low B of a 7 string. no offense JP7 fans, i think the low B on the 25.5s are too floppy and dont sound very tight.

    on the other hand, people dont like how sharp the high strings sound on the 27.0, i dont mind it so much.

    obviously the longer scale has very large fret spaces down towards the nut, and some stretchy chords will be very difficult

    it also makes slapping techniques much easier on the long scaler

  4. #4
    Hendog's Avatar
    Hendog is offline Registered User Senior Member
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    giving the Count of Tuscany a Glasgow Kiss
    Posts
    732
    It sounds like you guys are saying that a 27" scale is actually better?

    Is there any reason to go 25.5"?
    Guitars: EBMM JP 6, EBMM 25th, Ibanez 7 string, Carvin DC127 (on order)
    Amps: Mark V, HT-5, Cube 30, Hot Rod Deluxe, many cabs
    Effects: Carbon Copy, DD-20, Cry Baby Wah, Pitchblack, EVH Phaser


    Great deals with frisco, Astronome, and others

  5. #5
    Hendog's Avatar
    Hendog is offline Registered User Senior Member
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    giving the Count of Tuscany a Glasgow Kiss
    Posts
    732
    bump
    Guitars: EBMM JP 6, EBMM 25th, Ibanez 7 string, Carvin DC127 (on order)
    Amps: Mark V, HT-5, Cube 30, Hot Rod Deluxe, many cabs
    Effects: Carbon Copy, DD-20, Cry Baby Wah, Pitchblack, EVH Phaser


    Great deals with frisco, Astronome, and others

  6. #6
    patpark is offline Registered User Senior Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Location
    Orange County, CA
    Posts
    761
    it's all a matter of preference. the longer scale makes for tighter string tension. bending the strings takes more force (strings are tighter)

    25.5" is pretty much standard for most guitars and offers the best compromise between playability and good tone. the longer scale is really for guys who want more tension or need to tune lower. if your happy with 25.5 I don't see any reason to change. if your looking to expand with lower tunings, then look into a baritone guitar.

  7. #7
    walleye is offline Registered User Senior Member
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    Melbourne, Australia
    Posts
    433
    Quote Originally Posted by Hendog View Post
    It sounds like you guys are saying that a 27" scale is actually better?

    Is there any reason to go 25.5"?
    well for a 7 string id definitely go 27.0
    for a 6 string 25.5

    maybe if the guitar was going to played in a metal-only band (and for some reason 7s werent an option) i might consider 27.0

  8. #8
    JP7Nomad is offline Registered User Junior Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Posts
    167
    IMO, 27" is completely unnecessary.

    Adding the inch and a half to the scale compromises the tone of the higher strings to add roughly a pound of tension to all of the strings. If you want to add a pound of tension - use a thicker gauge.

  9. #9
    Hendog's Avatar
    Hendog is offline Registered User Senior Member
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    giving the Count of Tuscany a Glasgow Kiss
    Posts
    732
    Quote Originally Posted by JP7Nomad View Post
    IMO, 27" is completely unnecessary.

    Adding the inch and a half to the scale compromises the tone of the higher strings to add roughly a pound of tension to all of the strings. If you want to add a pound of tension - use a thicker gauge.
    Is it unnecessary for a 7 string?

    So the lower notes sound better but the higher notes sound worse?
    Guitars: EBMM JP 6, EBMM 25th, Ibanez 7 string, Carvin DC127 (on order)
    Amps: Mark V, HT-5, Cube 30, Hot Rod Deluxe, many cabs
    Effects: Carbon Copy, DD-20, Cry Baby Wah, Pitchblack, EVH Phaser


    Great deals with frisco, Astronome, and others

  10. #10
    JP7Nomad is offline Registered User Junior Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Posts
    167
    Quote Originally Posted by Hendog View Post
    Is it unnecessary for a 7 string?

    So the lower notes sound better but the higher notes sound worse?
    I feel it's unnecessary, yes.

    The higher notes sound shrill due to that extra length. The lower notes tighten up a little bit, but it's no different than just going up in string gauge.

  11. #11
    walleye is offline Registered User Senior Member
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    Melbourne, Australia
    Posts
    433
    then the answer is multiscale fanned fret

    problems with that are: hard to make it with a tremolo bridge

    attracts annoying questions from other guitarists who use words like "dog" and "bro" alot

    thats about it really

    just a quick google images if you dont know what im talking about:


  12. #12
    walleye is offline Registered User Senior Member
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    Melbourne, Australia
    Posts
    433
    Quote Originally Posted by JP7Nomad View Post
    The lower notes tighten up a little bit, but it's no different than just going up in string gauge.
    well if youre satisfied with the B on a 25.5 then obviously dont go up in scale

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •