Ok - I'll fess up. I actually own two Hootie CD's. So now I guess I must defend my honor.
Are these guys the most talented instrumentalists, musically gifted composers or provacatively creative lyricists? - No. They were just a working college bar band that caught a break with an interesting name, some catchy pop tunes at the end of the grunge era and Letterman being a fan. I think Darius Rucker has a good voice, but the other guys are fairly run of the mill.
I also think they get stuck with the " Hey I'm better than these guys....how come they're making it " backlash that often hits people of average talent who have made it in any field. Sometimes it's not fair that the ultra talented don't aren't always rewarded for their efforts. But, on the other hand, these guys are not some producers invention as fronts for studio musicians and a paycheck. They were out playing, got lucky and rolled with it.
Now let's fess up - How many of you guys workng clubs on weekends wouldn't mind being discovered, signed, sell a few million albums and get some national tours. (I can hear it now "...yeah but my music is good...")

(Well at least when you were 25 and single)
At this point I think these guys still tour, back to clubs of course, put out the occasional album and run an annual charity golf tournament benefitting education. Just back to being working musicians.
I'm not the president of the hootie fanclub, nor do I play him on TV. But I had to defend myself and say my piece - now let the greene bashing begin
