GuitarHack
Well-known member
- Joined
- Jun 22, 2006
- Messages
- 981
Lately, I've really been dwelling on the idea that some guitars have "it", and some don't, and how that comes to pass. I can't precisely define "it", but I bet most folks here know what I mean.
This weekend, I confirmed it's not a function of quality or price. I auditioned with a new band, and I took a non-EBMM $3300 boutique guitar I own. I did this because the bass player is a big fan of this brand, and begged me to bring it. This guitar is GREAT, it sounds and looks amazing, it is versatile and responsive, and...boring and cold and lifeless. I can't explain it. I haven't a single complaint about this guitar, it is perfect, and it leaves me numb. Perfect sound, perfect frets, perfect looks....yawn.
I could theoretically love this guitar, and be monagamous 'til death do us part, but I can't. WTF???
Toward the end of the audition, I switched to my 20th Aniversary Silo, and BAM! I wasn't in the zone, I was in somebody else's zone! I literally played stuff I couldn't play! Even the other guys there mentioned that I really seemed to be into it, and knew my stuff. I couldn't get a bad sound, and I didn't want to stop.
So...how does the mojo get baked in? I don't mean to be a suck up, but ALL of my EBMMs have "it", which is amazing to me (and granted, the quality is second to none). I had two Gibson LPs, one had it, one didn't. I had a $2400 boutique Tele-style axe that didn't have it, and a $269 Mexican Tele that did. I'm sure someone else out there can remember a $2000+ custom guitar that didn't have it, and a $200 pawn shop POS that did.
So, to bring this back to EBMM and the consistent "vibe"...do the guitars spring from the Ball family and Dudley's and SL/AL/JP/SM's imagination with all of the mojo that can be had, or does the design team have to iterate the design until it is "right" in that undefinable way? I expect the answer is the latter, so the real question then is, If a guitar you're making doesn't have that special secret something, what happens then? What do you add to make a guitar come to life, have a personality, and be magical? I can't imagine someone says, "Hey, this axe isn't happening...let's change the fret size and the neck pickup", and that's how magic happens?
It makes me think that some guitar makers have "it", and some don't.
Sorry for the rambling, but, am I making any sense?
This weekend, I confirmed it's not a function of quality or price. I auditioned with a new band, and I took a non-EBMM $3300 boutique guitar I own. I did this because the bass player is a big fan of this brand, and begged me to bring it. This guitar is GREAT, it sounds and looks amazing, it is versatile and responsive, and...boring and cold and lifeless. I can't explain it. I haven't a single complaint about this guitar, it is perfect, and it leaves me numb. Perfect sound, perfect frets, perfect looks....yawn.
Toward the end of the audition, I switched to my 20th Aniversary Silo, and BAM! I wasn't in the zone, I was in somebody else's zone! I literally played stuff I couldn't play! Even the other guys there mentioned that I really seemed to be into it, and knew my stuff. I couldn't get a bad sound, and I didn't want to stop.
So...how does the mojo get baked in? I don't mean to be a suck up, but ALL of my EBMMs have "it", which is amazing to me (and granted, the quality is second to none). I had two Gibson LPs, one had it, one didn't. I had a $2400 boutique Tele-style axe that didn't have it, and a $269 Mexican Tele that did. I'm sure someone else out there can remember a $2000+ custom guitar that didn't have it, and a $200 pawn shop POS that did.
So, to bring this back to EBMM and the consistent "vibe"...do the guitars spring from the Ball family and Dudley's and SL/AL/JP/SM's imagination with all of the mojo that can be had, or does the design team have to iterate the design until it is "right" in that undefinable way? I expect the answer is the latter, so the real question then is, If a guitar you're making doesn't have that special secret something, what happens then? What do you add to make a guitar come to life, have a personality, and be magical? I can't imagine someone says, "Hey, this axe isn't happening...let's change the fret size and the neck pickup", and that's how magic happens?
It makes me think that some guitar makers have "it", and some don't.
Sorry for the rambling, but, am I making any sense?