• Ernie Ball
  • MusicMan
  • Sterling by MusicMan

Four Eyes

Active member
Joined
Nov 9, 2008
Messages
34
Location
Lakewood, WA
Greetings all!

Just picked up a SUB1 last week and I love it. I can't put it down. So much so that I barely made it through my gig last night because of the hand fatigue I gave myself.

The guitar I picked up is a hardtail and came with the standard tuners. Being a long-time fan of locking tuners, I am wondering if anyone can help me figure out which brand would be a direct retrofit for my new baby.

Thanks gang.
 

Kaloyan

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 27, 2009
Messages
274
Location
Glenview, IL
The guitar holds tune well without them either way but I have Schaller in one of my customs and I cant really tell the difference .... Weird eh?
 

Crimson Sunrise

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 18, 2002
Messages
128
I might have to change mine eventually. The original owner had just about stripped the flat-head locking tuners. I actually did a full set-up on my SUB1 yesterday night. It plays and sounds fantastic!
 

azazael

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 2, 2007
Messages
1,613
Location
Scotland
If you restring a guitar properly and stretch the strings in locking tuners are in no way needed. I have cheap guitars that maintain perfect tuning with this method.
 

Crimson Sunrise

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 18, 2002
Messages
128
If you restring a guitar properly and stretch the strings in locking tuners are in no way needed. I have cheap guitars that maintain perfect tuning with this method.

They are for me. I want a FAST string change. I have no time for wrappin' string around the post, while leaving a chance of string slippage. And of course, string stretching is always necessary.
 

Four Eyes

Active member
Joined
Nov 9, 2008
Messages
34
Location
Lakewood, WA
If you restring a guitar properly and stretch the strings in locking tuners are in no way needed....


True, the stock tuners on my Sub work fine and hold tune fairly well. But for the sake of argument, my stock strap buttons worked equally as well, but I still elected to use straplocks.

It's a matter of personal preferance I guess...I change strings farily frequently when I'm on the road, never putting more than two shows on a set before they're swapped out. Having locking tuners for me is purely a matter of convenience. It's alot easier to change strings in a moving vehicle or a dressing room couch when all you have to do is thread 'em through, lock 'em down, stretch 'em out and tune 'em up.
 

azazael

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 2, 2007
Messages
1,613
Location
Scotland
I never get slippage... ever.
Its all in the method.

I also think having good windings helps resonance.
 

B2D

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 19, 2005
Messages
644
Location
Orange County, CA
If you restring a guitar properly and stretch the strings in locking tuners are in no way needed. I have cheap guitars that maintain perfect tuning with this method.

I will agree with this. Locking tuners aren't essential for me but they are appreciated. I find quality tuners help sustain, as well. My MIM strat gained a lot of sustain when i changed from the stock tuners to Sperzels. I've never noticed a difference on winds vs. no winds with locking tuners, though. I usually put one full wind on just in case the lock fails.

Also, having a well-done nut helps. Cheap ones that aren't well-cut can sometimes bind up the strings at the slots. Having a well-cut/filed nut with a little lube in it helps.
 

Kaloyan

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 27, 2009
Messages
274
Location
Glenview, IL
True, the stock tuners on my Sub work fine and hold tune fairly well. But for the sake of argument, my stock strap buttons worked equally as well, but I still elected to use straplocks.

It's a matter of personal preferance I guess...I change strings farily frequently when I'm on the road, never putting more than two shows on a set before they're swapped out. Having locking tuners for me is purely a matter of convenience. It's alot easier to change strings in a moving vehicle or a dressing room couch when all you have to do is thread 'em through, lock 'em down, stretch 'em out and tune 'em up.

I think you just WANT to install locking tuners ... you really dont NEED to ... something like idea-fix ... Go for it man ... you wont damage anything
 

John C

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 16, 2004
Messages
973
Location
Kansas City
Actually I'm not sure the Schallers are direct replacements on the SUB1 guitars; I belive those guitars used EBMM-branded Gotoh tuners (while all the other EBMM guitars do use Schaller tuners).

The one I had briefly (I tend to not keep bolt-neck humbucker guitars around for very long :eek:) had the old-style Gotoh Magnum tuners where you had to use a coin to unscrew/rescrew the locking top part of the post.

Again, I'm not sure you wouldn't have to do a little drilling to use Schallers.
 

MusicManJP6

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 31, 2007
Messages
1,453
Location
Greenville, SC
I'd love to have a Sub1 w/ fixed bridge for drop tunings!! I've even got a spare set of original JP pickups I could install. Can you say, "Working Man's JP"?!
 

jamminjim

Well-known member
Joined
May 25, 2006
Messages
2,303
Location
Grand Junction, Colorado
Hey John C - I looked at the Gotoh magnums and the stock Sub 1 lockers don't seem to be exactly like them. The Sub 1's lockers posts are taller and the mounting nut seems different. Maybe an older, or a previous style Gotoh magnum was like that, I don't know. They may have been made by Gotoh, but I tend to think they were sourced from a different company; could be wrong though.

Anyway, the Sub 1 locking tuner has the twin posts underneath, like the Fe$der schaller, that keep the tuner aligned on the headstock and the posts are hidden when the tuner is mounted. A EBMM schaller will cover up the holes, but you have to drill an additional one to mount, as mentioned.

I am curious to know if a Fe$der schaller locking tuner would fit? But I may never know, as I don't have any Fe$der guitars. I'm sure some knucks do though, and could do the research. Hint Hint... :)

Anyway, I want lockers on my subs to make it easier/quicker to work on the guitar, to take the strings off temporarily to get to the innards easily, then put the strings back on. Locking tuners make this process one heck of alot simpler. I think that's the one thing that hasn't been mentioned. Now some would say that isn't a necessity, however for what I do with my subs, it almost would be considered so. Tuning stability isn't the issue in this case.
 

John C

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 16, 2004
Messages
973
Location
Kansas City
Hey John C - I looked at the Gotoh magnums and the stock Sub 1 lockers don't seem to be exactly like them. The Sub 1's lockers posts are taller and the mounting nut seems different. Maybe an older, or a previous style Gotoh magnum was like that, I don't know. They may have been made by Gotoh, but I tend to think they were sourced from a different company; could be wrong though.

Anyway, the Sub 1 locking tuner has the twin posts underneath, like the Fe$der schaller, that keep the tuner aligned on the headstock and the posts are hidden when the tuner is mounted. A EBMM schaller will cover up the holes, but you have to drill an additional one to mount, as mentioned.

I am curious to know if a Fe$der schaller locking tuner would fit? But I may never know, as I don't have any Fe$der guitars. I'm sure some knucks do though, and could do the research. Hint Hint... :)

Anyway, I want lockers on my subs to make it easier/quicker to work on the guitar, to take the strings off temporarily to get to the innards easily, then put the strings back on. Locking tuners make this process one heck of alot simpler. I think that's the one thing that hasn't been mentioned. Now some would say that isn't a necessity, however for what I do with my subs, it almost would be considered so. Tuning stability isn't the issue in this case.

Jim - these were an earlier version of the Gotohs - instead of being "self-locking" like the current ones the top half screws on and off (kind of like the thumbscrew on the top of a current PRS tuner). I had seen these tuners on the Ibanez Starfield guitars back in the early 1990s. Since this was an earlier style you could be right that they were sourced somewhere other than Gotoh (maybe the Korean company that made the pickups for the SUB 1).

I'm not sure about the Fender/Schallers; seems like they have a different "footprint" than the SUB tuners but if the posts are in the same spot they could work.
 
Top Bottom