Rosewood vs. Maple board

[candid_x]

There are some typical tone differences between identical guitars but with different finger board materials, such as, maple being brighter, spankier and sometimes more articulate, whereas rosewood tends to be warmer and fatter.

But, has anyone here had otherwise identical guitars, say – one rosewood and one maple – experienced that the rosewood board produces significantly louder acoustical tone and vibrates/transmits noticeably more in the hand?

 

[koogie2k]

Well, at one point, I had 2 Tom Anderson's prior to finding EBMM. Both identical guitars, minus color, and one was a rosewood and the other was maple. I found the tones the exact way you stated.

However, I thought the maple tend to be more acoustic. I only base this because I thought it just sounded brighter (louder) even acoustically. But, I did find the rosewood to resonate and sustain longer acoustically...but was warmer in sound (not as loud as maple).

At this point, I only play EBMM JP guitars and bongo basses. All rosewood as I like it better than maple. The rosewood Axis is one of my favorites as the rosewood neck is flat out to die for.

 

[jaxadam]

I think maple has a little more bite or snappiness to it.

 

[wired]

I prefer maple a fretboard more because it feels smoother to me when playing.
I only have one electric w/ a rosewood fretboard (Axis Sport) & it does sound different than my EVH, Wolfies & Silhouette Special (all w/ maple fb), but I attribute it more to the wood used for the body (Ash vs Basswood vs Alder).

 

[Roubster]

I personally love rosewood, because I like that nice dark and warm fat sound more. Also, Alder is a bright enough wood, so I kind of like the balance between the two. Oh, and also I mostly preffer the LOOK of rosewood compared to maple. So far all the guitars I have are all rosewood, but I might get a maple one at some point, hopefully with A LOT of figuring. That's the only time I like maple board if you can see TONS of figuring on it, like that early Silo Jon is about to buy from the Bay .

 

[jaxadam]

maple baby!

 

[Roubster]

What is that abomination?!?!?! j/k Is that your Jem? And I see you got the Spider 2, do you like it? I've got one, but I am getting really sick of it. The Flex3 is cool tho.
I am starting to like Maple a little more from seeing some nice figured ones, and it feels nice too, but that maple on the Jem is way too plain. If I had a lot of money I would have odered another 20th Silo w/ maple.

 

[jaxadam]

That guitar plays like a BEAST! Sounds and plays GREAT!

I really like the Spider II, the 2 X 12 version.

That is one of like the 20 guitars I have, plus, I have a super duper set-up where I can get just about any sound I want out of it.

 

[groovetuber]

maple baby!

Nice Jem dude! I love those early Jems.

 

[jongitarz]

maple baby!

It looks like Walt Disney threw up

 

[NorM]

It looks like Walt Disney threw up

What movie starring Burt Renoylds and Dom DeLouis (sp) had that line? One of them was trying to kill himself and threw up all the pills.

PS My new avatar. Above the mountians and the sun is actually Blue Dawn. I'm gonna go get a life now.

 

[Larry]

It looks like Walt Disney threw up

That it does.

 

[Jonny Dubai]

I have both a maple and a rosewood neck axis and ass. I thought i would not like the rosewood, but i was so wrong. The sound is a little meatier and the feeling.... unbelievable.


Jonny

 

[candid_x]

Thanks, all, especially Koogie, for speaking to my main question of acoustic volume.

I have two ‘like new’ SS, one with maple and one with rosewood. I’ve been playing a lot of both lately, but keep coming to the conclusion that the rosewood model resonates more in the neck, and is considerably louder acoustically. I’ve owned several of each boards, but this is the first I’ve owned the same model simultaneously where I could actually A/B them. I’ve nearly always been partial to maple, mainly for the slippery feel and spanky tone/response, and I prefer the look of maple better. But now I’m leaning strongly to rosewood, at least on the SS model.

Thanks again.

 

[Spudmurphy]

I can't comment on the differences but as my close up eyesight is getting worse I have noticed that the strings are difficult to see on a maple board when you are playing sat down peering towards the nut. No problem playing up the "dusty end" though.
Spud

 

[candid_x]

Spud, that's never occured to me ! Not a problem. I only know 7 notes anyway, and I've commited ALL of them to memory!

 

[robelinda2]

best just to have a few EBMM guitars with maple and rosewood, i'll have 4 of each when my orders come in! I notice the difference with my two Axis SS's, the maple one is much brighter, and plays differently too. The r'wood one feels softer and darker, but of course i could be talking out of my ass and its all just a visual thing or some crazy "Eric Johnson battery thing", plus different pickups counts too.

 

[threeminutesboy]

I agree with you !

the feeling between Axis mapple and Axis SS MM 90 rosewood is really not the same will not play the same way at all !

personally, I must admit I love the(EBMM) rosewood neck a bit more than the mapple one

 

[GWDavis28]

What movie starring Burt Renoylds and Dom DeLouis (sp) had that line? One of them was trying to kill himself and threw up all the pills.

The End!!!

Glenn |B)

 

[GWDavis28]

It looks like Walt Disney threw up

Jon, man you kill me, that made my morning.

Glenn |B)