• Ernie Ball
  • MusicMan
  • Sterling by MusicMan

bassmonkey

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 4, 2005
Messages
908
Location
Perth, Australia
1/5 of the time? a 16th?? How much time do you spend riding the E?

Good point.

I'm just trying to figure out how useful that B would be. I see a lot of 5 players who hardly seem to touch the low B. I wouldn't want to get one and not bother with the extra string.
 

Mobay45

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 3, 2004
Messages
4,597
Location
Home of the Bongo Birthday Bash '06
Good point.

I'm just trying to figure out how useful that B would be. I see a lot of 5 players who hardly seem to touch the low B. I wouldn't want to get one and not bother with the extra string.

It's just like sitting down to dinner.

You have a knife, a fork and a spoon. You can usually eat your whole meal without touching the spoon. But it sure is handy to have around when you need it.
 

tkarter

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 22, 2004
Messages
5,921
Location
Kansas
The easiest way to answer your question would be to ask yourself how many times you feel you need to hear something lower than the E string is voiced on your 4?

If you prescribe to not playing open strings you will tend to use the B a bunch as Larry suggested earlier.

IMHO it is much easier to use the B when it is needed if you have one. It also isn't much trouble to play the original 4 strings.

What I would worry about were I you is loving the 5 string so much I had no use for those 4 stringers any longer. :D

tk
 

shamus63

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 8, 2005
Messages
4,018
Location
San Mateo, CA
Interesting - I haven't tried a 5 string bass before properly, and have always felt happy with what my 4 string basses offer me. Never really felt the need to consider an extra string...

After reading all your comments a rethink may be in order .... I am now curious to try a 5 stringer to see how they play and sound ...
Shamus and Mobay both seem to suggest a better tone from a 5 string, why is that? - is that because you can use the low B?

I don't know that I'd say better, just prefered (most of the time, anyway).

I don't know if the pickups are voiced differently, but I'd have to reason that the extra body mass of a 5'r (no matter how slight) would affect the overall tone (compared to its 4-string counterpart).

IMHO.
 

bassmonkey

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 4, 2005
Messages
908
Location
Perth, Australia
What I would worry about were I you is loving the 5 string so much I had no use for those 4 stringers any longer. :D

tk

<fingers in ears> La la la, not listening!</fingers in ears>

Aaaarrggh, I'm getting serious GAS! Must........resist..........must.........resist!

Now all I need is for BP to come on this thread and order me to buy a 5er, like he did to me with my 30th! :(
 

tkarter

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 22, 2004
Messages
5,921
Location
Kansas
<fingers in ears> La la la, not listening!</fingers in ears>

Aaaarrggh, I'm getting serious GAS! Must........resist..........must.........resist!

Now all I need is for BP to come on this thread and order me to buy a 5er, like he did to me with my 30th! :(


Seriously after playing my SR5 a year and not touching my last 4 stringer I gave the 4 away.

tk
 

mike not fat

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 5, 2004
Messages
488
5'ers are to heavy for my thin shoulders. But I strung the bongo 4 with 65-130 strings and tuned it DGCF. I realized that most of the time I play in the 17 first frets, so tuning down expands the possibilities on the low side.

I love the deepnes of those bigger strings, the extra low action I can get + in some songs we play I need a low D, so i don't need to tune down or up. Give it a try ; you'll easily get used to it.

MNF
 

adouglas

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 12, 2005
Messages
5,592
Location
On the tail end of the bell curve in Connecticut
5'ers are to heavy for my thin shoulders.

407158.jpg

http://www.musiciansfriend.com/product/Levys-412-Padded-Leather-Bass-Guitar-Strap?sku=369224

Levy's 4-1/2" wide padded strap. Spread the weight, lose the pain. Works great. Any wider and the edge would be off your shoulder anyway.

This $0.02 brought to you by a guy who owned a Peavy T-40 25-odd years ago. My back still hurts. MM 5ers are light as a feather by comparison.
 

mike not fat

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 5, 2004
Messages
488
This $0.02 brought to you by a guy who owned a Peavy T-40 25-odd years ago. My back still hurts. MM 5ers are light as a feather by comparison.

of course, but I'm only weihing something like 118 lbs. (54 kg), so even with a good strap, and even a MM, that's to much for me ! Even the 4 HH feels sometimes heavy after 3 hours playing without sitting !

And don't advise me to eat more, I eat much, but don't go heavier...that's just how I am.

MNF
 
Top Bottom