It really depends on what you intend to do with it. The Blackheart looks superior in every way. I have a Valve Special that I bought just for recording at home and it gets some pretty good saturated and crunchy blues tones but is way to dark and muddy for my tastes. I guess I just prefer Fender style clean tones. Neither amp will do metal. Don't overlook a Fender champ either, it smokes the valve junior.