stu42
Well-known member
Thanks for the info.
I had the Dunlops a looong time ago (probably 20 years ago) and I got rid of them because I noticed over time that the part that attached to the strap (call this the "locking part") started developing more and more play when inserted into the button. When I let the guitar hang naturally the locking part looked like it was just barely holding on - which didn't give me a lot of confidence.
So, I switched to the Schallers because I just think they're inherently more secure. But, I don't like the rattle and squeek they make. The solution to that is DO NOT attach the locking part to the strap. What I do now is just put the strap onto the Schaller button, as you would a normal strap button, and then I fit the locking part onto the button. That way, the strap is sandwiched between the guitar and the locking part. Voila...secure, and no more noise.
When some people had rumoured that the E.B. strap locks would fit over top of the existing strap buttons I thought they would work this way. I guess not though. If I have to change the button that's okay. The main benefit I see of the E.B. strap locks over the Schallers is that you get to use the same size/diameter of screw as the stock ones - which is a significant advantage because otherwise you have to drill out the guitar, glue in a dowel and then drill a smaller diameter hole for the Schaller screw/button...which is a pain and makes no sense!!!
I'm thinking I could use the "sandwich" approach with the E.B. system as well if I want - which is cool with me. On the other hand, if the E.B. locking part fits more securely than the Dunlop system then that would be better as well.
I had the Dunlops a looong time ago (probably 20 years ago) and I got rid of them because I noticed over time that the part that attached to the strap (call this the "locking part") started developing more and more play when inserted into the button. When I let the guitar hang naturally the locking part looked like it was just barely holding on - which didn't give me a lot of confidence.
So, I switched to the Schallers because I just think they're inherently more secure. But, I don't like the rattle and squeek they make. The solution to that is DO NOT attach the locking part to the strap. What I do now is just put the strap onto the Schaller button, as you would a normal strap button, and then I fit the locking part onto the button. That way, the strap is sandwiched between the guitar and the locking part. Voila...secure, and no more noise.
When some people had rumoured that the E.B. strap locks would fit over top of the existing strap buttons I thought they would work this way. I guess not though. If I have to change the button that's okay. The main benefit I see of the E.B. strap locks over the Schallers is that you get to use the same size/diameter of screw as the stock ones - which is a significant advantage because otherwise you have to drill out the guitar, glue in a dowel and then drill a smaller diameter hole for the Schaller screw/button...which is a pain and makes no sense!!!
I'm thinking I could use the "sandwich" approach with the E.B. system as well if I want - which is cool with me. On the other hand, if the E.B. locking part fits more securely than the Dunlop system then that would be better as well.