• Ernie Ball
  • MusicMan
  • Sterling by MusicMan

Soulkeeper

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
216
Location
Bergen, Norway
After losing my SR5 almost a decade ago (it was stolen by some creature for which I have no words suitable for a public forum), I finally treated myself to a "new" SR5 about a year ago. It was a used HH with a maple neck, and at a great price.

Despite the fact that it was a SR5, in my world the ultimate bass, the instrument just didn't feel right in my hands. I decided that it was the extra pickup altering the feel of the whole setup. So a couple of weeks ago I bought a single pickup 2002 SR5 with rosewood fretboard (looking almost identical to the one I lost). And I'm absolutely astounded by the difference in feel. The 2002 bass definitely feels right for me, as opposed to the HH. I don't know if it's just the lack of the extra pickup that does it, or maybe the rosewood fretboard, or if it's visually induced placebo or some strange mojo voodoo thing, but for me a SR5 HH with a maple neck is a totally different beast from a SR5 H with a rosewood fingerboard ... apparently. I don't understand it, but it is what it is.

But the story isn't over yet. After spending so much time on various used instrument sites online, I noticed this nice fretless SR5 H that was being sold for a very reasonable price. I read some online reviews and comments about the SR5 fretless, and unsurprisingly everybody seemed to think it's a great instrument. I've always wanted to learn to play a fretless properly. Many years ago I actually ruined a cheap five stringer (my first bass) in an unsuccessful attempt to convert it into a fretless. (It's still salvagable, though, just give me some years and a wood workshop.)

Anyway, by now I was so deeply entrenched in my "scouring the Internet for used SR5s" process, that I found I couldn't stop myself before I'd also bought the fretless, which is hopefully en route right now. I had to present myself with two excuses; The fact that I've wanted to play fretless for almost 20 years now, and the fact that my birthday was just around the corner. But it worked. I had successfully persuaded myself.

So I ordered my fourth EBMM SR5 bass, and soon I'll have three SR5s in my possession. I do not run a music shop or a studio. I am not a professional musician. So, now to the real question: Should I go have my head examined?
 

tbonesullivan

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 24, 2012
Messages
2,410
Location
New Jersey
Keep in mind that the electronics for the various SR5's have changed over the years, from Alnico Magnets, to Ceramic, back to Alnico. also many feel that maple is a bit more "snappy" than rosewood.

any way, I'm currently working to get my sick SR5 repaired at the SLO hospital, so my plans for further SR5's are on hold until I figure out how much that will cost.
 

Movielife

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 7, 2003
Messages
1,340
Location
North West, UK
I imagine there might have been difference in the pickup material, (older Ray 5's being ceramic and having more of a mid bite, whereas 2008- have the traditional alnico Ray magnets).

Not all of the older ones are ceramic; I forget when the change was.

Nothing wrong with finding something that works for you and buying multiples...life is short, so enjoy it.
 

b-unit

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 10, 2006
Messages
528
I actually let my 2010 Sterling Silver SR5 go a few months ago in a trade as it just have the same vibe as my Trans Orange. I think it was the alnico versus ceramic thing. Or maybe its just that I am obsessed with transparent finishes! Funny thing is the trade allowed me to aquire my first EBMM guitar! I am the proud owner of a Silhouette Special now and am having a blast messing with one of the coolest and well designed guitars I have ever played.
 

Gravesend Black

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 13, 2012
Messages
427
Funny thing is the trade allowed me to aquire my first EBMM guitar! I am the proud owner of a Silhouette Special now and am having a blast messing with one of the coolest and well designed guitars I have ever played.
My wife is beginner guitar player and she was a worshipper of Gibson guitars. I've decided to change her mind and showed a couple of Silhouette videos on youtube. No more Gibson worshippers at my house!)
 

Soulkeeper

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
216
Location
Bergen, Norway
If you live close to Warwick NY, and you get bored with so many beautiful SR5's, give me a shout. :) Oh and Congrats...

Thanks. I live very far from Warwick NY. The poor postal folks have had to haul all my new-bought basses all the way to Norway.

I imagine there might have been difference in the pickup material, (older Ray 5's being ceramic and having more of a mid bite, whereas 2008- have the traditional alnico Ray magnets).

Not all of the older ones are ceramic; I forget when the change was.

Nothing wrong with finding something that works for you and buying multiples...life is short, so enjoy it.
Actually I believe this particular HH has ceramic magnets, and that MM changed to AlNiCo only about a week after its DOB. Now I've found a buyer for it, btw, so now I'm back to two SR5s, and I'm perfectly content with that.

Except that a Silhouette would be a nice way to complete the "collection" ... :rolleyes:

And I want to start nagging MM about making a 4 string Silhouette style bass. And an SR4 style guitar. Just for completeness. And for total awesomeness. :D

Nah, I'll try to keep myself in check. Still got loans to pay down.

I actually let my 2010 Sterling Silver SR5 go a few months ago in a trade as it just have the same vibe as my Trans Orange. I think it was the alnico versus ceramic thing. Or maybe its just that I am obsessed with transparent finishes! Funny thing is the trade allowed me to aquire my first EBMM guitar! I am the proud owner of a Silhouette Special now and am having a blast messing with one of the coolest and well designed guitars I have ever played.
Transparent (or semi transparent) is the bee's knees. As long as the instrument is made of wood, I want to see that wood! Congratulations with the Silhouette. I'd like to try one one day. If it's as well designed and made as the SR5 (and I have no reason to believe it's not), playing one must be heavenly.

Keep in mind that the electronics for the various SR5's have changed over the years, from Alnico Magnets, to Ceramic, back to Alnico. also many feel that maple is a bit more "snappy" than rosewood.

any way, I'm currently working to get my sick SR5 repaired at the SLO hospital, so my plans for further SR5's are on hold until I figure out how much that will cost.

Yes, the more I think about it, the more I'm convinced that the RW/maple thing is actually really noticable. I've had a bit of the same feeling when trying out telecasters with RW or maple necks, and I prefer RW on guitars too, but not to the same degree as with basses, apparently.

I can't say that one sounds worse than the other, or is more or less difficult to play, but maple just feel cold and hard and ... impersonal, sort of. To me, that is. Tastes differ.
 
Last edited:
Top Bottom