bkrumme
Well-known member
I wouldn't give up on the overdrive pedal if it contributes good, colorful tone and gain into the amp. I have a 5150 Combo, (I know, it's not in the same league as a Mark IV) and I use an overdrive pedal with it because it makes the amp sound better.
I've found that if I turn the gain down on my amp, and run an overdrive in front of the amp, I get a more toneful, transparent and useable gain than if I were to use only the gain produced by my amp.
The 5150 Combo at the lower gain setting (on the Rythym channel with the Crunch button out) without the overdrive pedal on allows me to have a relatively decent clean sound with the volume on my guitar rolled back to 6 or 7, and a good 70's rock guitar tone with the guitar volume on 10. With the Crunch button in, you can get good higher gain rythym tones, and great lead tones with the overdrive on. On the lead channel, with the gain rolled back and the overdrive off, you get a good heavy rythym tone, and an insane lead gain with the overdrive on. The overdrive pedal is almost like a 3rd and 4th channel on my amp.
I'm completely with you here. That's the exact reason I have an overdrive pedal in the first place. The one I have is good, but not great. I'd love to get into an overdrive that can give me really smooth, buttery overdrive. That's a different thread, though.
I was thinking about your comment earlier that I should get a buffered pedal, specifically a Boss and I remembered I have a Boss OS-2 at home that I'm not using. I could always throw that in the chain to use as a buffer.