That 1953 comment always strikes me as funny.
Take me for instance I love basses of all shapes and sizes..The Bongo and this new Axis bass design included. But there are certain playing situations I'm involved in that call for a certain look per say. I sometimes play with a Johnny Cash Tribute artist. If not playing my upright I will play my P bass or MM SR because they look the part being more traditional in design. A non-traditional looking bass may not fit as well, ....
Spot on comment with: 'A certain look per se'''...for me, I have this wrestling match every tour, every gig...my drummer asks: are you going to bring the Ric/P/Hoff?...for no other reason that having a credible 'look'..oy, and paisley, yeah, I wear pajamas on stage. Credible for who though? that's a good question, it ain't our immediate audience. Maybe the other bass player in the band cares, but, hey, I just want to use his Amp.
Anyhow, I just tell him 'NO'...I'm going to use what works best for the live situation'.
My Ray4HH is my main bass live, this ain't 'IMHO', I'm right, I'm the bass player, that's my job and it works for the gig. This happens every damn gig, and he LIKES the Ray.
Hey..I get it too...I own all the Bass Greatest Hits and use them too, but not live.
When we say a "non-traditional bass may not fit as well"...we're talking mostly about the look right?, certainly not just the sound, because alot of basses, no matter who makes 'em..work, and work well, whether you prefer your EQ on the bass, or off the bass, we're coloring that tone somwhere.
Anthony Jackson said it best and I'm paraphrasing from memory of an article from 1990 about the 6 string bass and all the resistance he's seen, 'as bassists, it's our job to move forward and open new doors, even if those doors have to be kicked '
Sumpin' like that.
And resisting change, I think it's more than that.. I mean a whole group of youngin's who didn't grow up in the 60s, 70s...gulp...80s. that sport some of this mindset too...could be marketing, now that's IMHO
Whew, now what was that about French Bow...which everyone knows is the best way...
MK