• Ernie Ball
  • MusicMan
  • Sterling by MusicMan

jlepre

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 30, 2007
Messages
3,020
Location
Parsippany, NJ, United States
Think of "Music Man" as an adjective.

Q: What type of basses do you play?
A: Music Man basses.

Q: What color is your car?
A: I have two silver cars.

You cannot say, "I drive silvers" and leave it at that. "I drive silver cars. I play Music Man basses."

These are just observations and are in no way legally binding.

Jack,
You said exactly what I was thinking...
 

coastie72

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 23, 2009
Messages
138
Location
Columbia SC
I like EBMM's, that works for me! Now that I've said that I guess I need to start looking for a Bongo so I can have EBMM's instead of a Music Man :D
 

Moose308

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 12, 2006
Messages
204
Location
British Columbia
Once you graduate from school, you are considered an Alumnus.
You and your former classmates are called Alumni.

If you walk in the desert, and see a prickly little lump, you call it a cactus.
Looking around you may see others, and so you see many cacti.

So, I own a Music Man. Actually, I own two. So I have two Music Mani?

:)
 

oddjob

Well-known member
Joined
May 12, 2004
Messages
2,839
Location
Monroe, Ohio
Think of "Music Man" as an adjective.

Q: What type of basses do you play?
A: Music Man basses.

Q: What color is your car?
A: I have two silver cars.

You cannot say, "I drive silvers" and leave it at that. "I drive silver cars. I play Music Man basses."

These are just observations and are in no way legally binding.

While this is true (and it is) it can also be considered a proper noun (which can stand alone... ie, "Look at that Music Man"). Because of that fact, it can be pluralized; however, it is not subject to the rules of irregular nouns (so, technically it is "Music Mans" when used as a plural proper noun). Actually, the reality of it is that the plural form of the noun, since it it is proper, is formed by standardized pluralization rules (with a few exceptions) UNLESS the person, place, thing, or idea says it spelled otherwise (in simple terms it is "Music Mans" unless BP says it is otherwise:D).
 
Last edited:

RobertB

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 5, 2007
Messages
1,657
Location
Denver area.
I love how people switch from webonics to proper spelling, grammar and punctuation in these kinds of discussions. I think I even saw the correct usage of a semicolon somewhere ... a semicolon! ;)
 

Ken Baker

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 4, 2007
Messages
289
Location
Behind the Orange Curtain
I've been waiting for just the right moment for that line. :eek:

===================

You've all been very helpful and informative. My quest for this little "dash" of punctuation is fulfilled.

Thank you all very much, with special thanks going out to Jack and Sterling for putting up with me.

Ken...
 

TNT

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 18, 2005
Messages
3,576
Location
Oakland - Raider Nation!
Precisely speaking it is "Music Adam". Which is a transliteration of the Hebrew - "man".

Adam represents the entire species as "one" creation. So, technically speaking:

Music Man is correct - great job BP; how'd you know that??!!
 

kevins

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 13, 2005
Messages
559
depends on the use lol, if its reffering to a collection of musicman basses "musicman basses" would be more than acceptable. in all cases i think the term "musicman" is actually an adjective noun, thats a noun being used as an adjective to further describe another noun.

on a funny side note apparently its proper to never ad the pluralization to a word modifying a noun

take this sentance
"i will have three whopper juniors"

junior is a modification on the word whopper so the proper english way to say it is

"i will have three whoppers junior"

also since musicman is a brand name or a title its probobly not proper to modify the name in other ways besides adding a s


coming from the guy who punctuates most of his sentaces with commas and hitting the enter key.
 
Last edited:

oddjob

Well-known member
Joined
May 12, 2004
Messages
2,839
Location
Monroe, Ohio
depends on the use lol, if its reffering to a collection of musicman basses "musicman basses" would be more than acceptable. in all cases i think the term "musicman" is actually an adjective noun, thats a noun being used as an adjective to further describe another noun.

on a funny side note apparently its proper to never ad the pluralization to a word modifying a noun

take this sentance
"i will have three whopper juniors"

junior is a modification on the word whopper so the proper english way to say it is

"i will have three whoppers junior"

also since musicman is a brand name or a title its probobly not proper to modify the name in other ways besides adding a s


coming from the guy who punctuates most of his sentaces with commas and hitting the enter key.

That is the great thng of American English... while the rule is true, AE has evolved its own set of rules and most of the time those modifiers actually become part of the "name" thus become part of the noun. In the Whopper case, "Junior" is actually considered to be part of the proper noun and not a modifier (even though it technically is).

I look at this and it is sad that I actually know and remember this stuff from my 2 years of master's level grammar classes (not that I use any of it... I just teach it :D)
 

drTStingray

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 25, 2007
Messages
1,833
Location
Kent, United Kingdom
Think of "Music Man" as an adjective.

Q: What type of basses do you play?
A: Music Man basses.

Q: What color is your car?
A: I have two silver cars.

You cannot say, "I drive silvers" and leave it at that. "I drive silver cars. I play Music Man basses."

These are just observations and are in no way legally binding.

I agree with these non-legally binding sentiments entirely.

....to put another slant on it............ I know people who always buy one type of car - they don't say 'I drive Ford cars' - they say 'I drive Fords'.

I know others who always play one sort of bass - they say 'I play only W*rw**ks' - I say nice place, very big castle - oh you're talking about basses, sorry I misunderstood.

I know others who say 'I play only F*n*ers' - I say hmmm you may need medication.

I agree you can't say 'I play Musicmen' sounds daft - and if you were in certain parts of this country you'd have to say 'I play Music gentlemen', or even 'Music chaps' -

I guess MusicMan basses is best.

Just be glad you don't have a collection of Gr**ch Country Gentlemans/men :D I wonder what they refer to them as!
 
Last edited:

kevins

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 13, 2005
Messages
559
That is the great thng of American English... while the rule is true, AE has evolved its own set of rules and most of the time those modifiers actually become part of the "name" thus become part of the noun. In the Whopper case, "Junior" is actually considered to be part of the proper noun and not a modifier (even though it technically is).

I look at this and it is sad that I actually know and remember this stuff from my 2 years of master's level grammar classes (not that I use any of it... I just teach it :D)

i love american english for that lol. i know a bunch of random etymological orgins of words and phrases and force myself to tell them at any moment i can.
 
Top Bottom