I'll try tossing in my 0.02.
Someone told me this once and I find it to be 100% true:
Most guitarists listen with their eyes.
What?
That's right. Most guitarists listen with their eyes.
If it doesnt look like a Marshall it cant have killer rock tone. If it isnt a LP, it cant have that early heavy rock sound. Etc.
People have a hard time getting past those stereotypes and image expectations.
If you really want to compare the the axis and the LP, go somewhere where you can really listen to the guitars.
Best world would be to put on a set of headphones from the out of a serious preamp/amp (however you have to do it, voodu valve, miked amp with phones from the board, whatever).
But even if all you can do is just plug into an amp that you know how to dial a great sound up on. Then close your eyes. Have your buddy hand you one and play it. Listen to it. Dont open your eyes. Then play the other. Sure, you will know which is which but if you really keep your eyes closed and listen I guarantee you can tell the difference.
I'm certainly not a great player. I am an average joe. But even I can hear the difference, particularly (IMHO) with the more recent Gibsons.
To me, I can just hear the overtones and harmonics jump off the fingerboard when I play the axis. the thing is so "live" to me. and i really think the pickups capture what I hear just acoustically.
on top of that, the neck is unbelievable. i wish it was just a tad wider. but that raw neck rules.
the LPs I tried, I felt that every one of them I would have had to upgraded the pickups. i have to also admit that I favor ebony or maple necks and most of the LPs I tried were Rosewood. I just hear more of a snap from those. I dont know why. Maybe that is me listening with my eyes
So go try them out--side to side, eyes closed. I think you will hear the difference. And I mean really HEAR the difference.
The thing you wont ever be able to get past with an axis is that it is a true "one look" guitar. It says Van Hagar. Period. And if you cant get past that connection and look, than all the listening with your ears wont get past the listening you are doing with your eyes.
Clark