I've done this three times now, most recently with a StingRay Special 5HH. After buying my first EBMM (JPX 6), I've completely trusted EBMM to build absolutely perfect guitars.
I have ordered two of soon-to-be-mine MM axes (see the signature) based on extensive (online) research, never having played a single one (where I live, it’s practically impossible to get your hands on a demo MM). Now, I am pondering an idea of ordering the third model. I have no doubts that they will exceed my expectations, both tonally, as as well as when overall quality is considered.
I've had 11 MusicMans (MusicMen?) (1 x Axis Sport, 2 x Axis Super Sport, 4 x Albert Lees, 1 x JP6, 1 x JPX-7, 1 x JP15, 1 x Valentine). Out of those, I got 7 unseen. They've all been amazing, as have those I selected after playing.
Recently though, I've struggled to find a Cutlass/Stingray that was as resonant/nice as the AL HH I played. However my JP15 is super new and an EPIC guitar.
So the only reason I'd hesitate is that I got damn spoiled so far! They're out there, but with so many guitas I don't play around the house, I'd rather play them and get one that's truly special.
I, too, bought my first MM ASS off of ebay in 2004. I have since bought 5 MM's online (two of them from overseas) without having played them before and never regretted it. I have never had any issues with all of these MM guitars.
Here's the deal IMHO - I think by and large one is very safe buying an EBMM online whether new or used. User abuse notwithstanding on the used side, one can be assured the craftsmanship will be top-notch.
I've purchased 7 over the years. 3 of them were sight unseen and I still have all three. Two of those three are Reflex's that I gig with the most. I haven't gigged without my Reflex Gamechanger since I got it. I would feel very safe buying one sight unseen.
My only problem with music man guitars is the ones that I buy are then discontinued. I'm like the kiss of death for music man guitar lines. I love my Armada and my Reflex's!
I'm fine buying mail order. Just make sure there's some kind of return policy. I've gotten a bunch of guitars through the mail from Musician's Friend, eBay, Kiesel, Music Go Round, and Music123. I've had good result with all.
Mine were all purchased without being played, although with Valentine and St Vincent I had been able to play other examples to get a general feel for the model
The only guitar I currently own that is one I personally played before buying is my 59 AVRI strat
I bought all of mine from the web. First one I got just on reputation of EBMM and my love of Dream Theater. After trying that JP6 I was hooked and bought a L3 and JP15 later. They are all superb.
Absolutely.. Infact that’s the only way I’ve ordered them. I don’t have the luxury of a guitar center or Sam ash here in my island in Hawaii. Luckily I’m a EBMM and SBMM artist and order directly from my artist representative but I’m never worried because EBMM guitars and basses are just the best fit for me.