DavidOfOz
Well-known member
...Although I'm going to stop here because it seems that this "forum" is so one sided that it's about to tilt over. While I'm sure a passion for music is present, surpassing that appears to be a passion for personal possesions.
Everone has missed the point as their focus is firmly their next aquisition.
It's been said you're not hurting anyone, ok, but you're sure not helping anyone either. Just pretty much accumlating more upon more flight cases filled with sparkly painted wood...
Sam, I think it is you who has missed the point. We get what you’re saying: the implication has been clear to begin with. You equate Ernie’s collection with wealth/materialism, and wealth with greed/selfishness. You have implied that Ernie should spend his money on helping others rather than increasing his collection.
The problem is, in making that point, you have made an uniformed assumption that Ernie doesn’t help others. That’s a judgement, and an unfair one at that. And you have offended people by making that judgement. You see this as a one-sided “discussion”. Members of this forum see it as an unprovoked/unfair/unnecessary/uninformed attack on Ernie. This forum is for the discussion of EBMM guitars, not politics, economics, materialism, globalisation, ethics or morals. And it’s not a forum for making judgements against other members.
Some people pay millions for a piece of paper with some paint splashed over it, and which some expert somewhere decrees to be art. The value of Ernie’s collection pales into significance compared to that, and yet, owning a painting isn’t usually deemed to be obsessive. Would you have been so incensed if Ernie had a $200,000 stamp or coin collection instead?
None of us has the right to judge what’s excessive for someone else, especially when the alleged excess is not hurting anyone. Ernie’s collection might seem excessive to you, but your single, solitary EBMM marks you as extremely wealthy when compared to many millions of people. To paraphrase an old proverb: don’t judge unless you want to be judged yourself.
It’s become pretty clear from posts by BP and Ernie himself that he does do a lot for others. (It should never have reached the point where Ernie needed to defend himself in such a manner.) It seems to me that your judgment was way off, and that the members of the forum have been right to be critical of your attack.
You can perceive this as being a one-sided discussion if your wish...or acknowledge that your judgment was off-base and move on to discussion of EBMM guitars. Your choice.